Beadell Tours logo

Back to Tyre Information

Site Map

 

Puncture Comparison Between Tyres for Long Range Desert Touring

    This is just a quick look at the results of our commercial tours over the years in relation to tyres and how things seem to work while travelling off-road, that’s roads like the Anne Beadell, Canning Stock Route & Gunbarrel Highway. We’ve simply listed the trip, how many flat tyres were recorded and then broken it down into what type of tyres had trouble.

    The tubeless tyres are pretty straight forward, 99% of the time they get damaged from sharp sticks. Then the odd weird thing like a spanner turns up, what can you do about that? Now when you scrutinise the tubed tyres for strength you have to take into account the flat tyres that were caused by the tubes & what we will call "old damage", which is when an old tyre with an outside cut that develops slowly and goes through the tyre to damage the tube & create a slow leak. Not many tourists will ever have this problem but we see it every now & again ourselves and it is worthy of recording. Tubes are a difficult thing to manage when running at low pressures for extended periods. The quality of rubber in tubes these days is not conducive to this sort of work, but as with most things there are a few tricks that make life easier, just a matter of whether you ever find them out. Another tube problem is customer lack of maintenance between yearly trips (we have quite a number of folk who regularly participate in our expeditions). The bulk of tube problems are due to poor fitting & poor maintenance. Split rims & tubes need regular inspections, dismounting, cleaning, fresh talc and refitting with silicone in the lock ring gap and valve slot to keep the sand & grit out of the tyre.

    Anyway have a look and see, it should be of interest if you are a thinker.

 

Year/Month Vehicles total Kms Flats total   Vehicles with T/L Wide T/L Radial Vehicles with tubes Radial tubed Bias tubed Tube flats Old damage   Mick's flats
2005 April 2 2462 2   0  -  2 2  -   -   -    1 ASR
2005 June 2 1293 2   1 2 1  -   -   -   -    0 ASR
2006 April 5 2130 1   0  -  5 1  -   -   -    1 ASR
2006 May 8 2403 0   5  -  3  -   -   -   -    0 ASR
2006 July 2 830 0   1  -  1  -   -   -   -    0 Bias
2007 April 5 2090 3   3 3 2  -   -   -   -    *0 SBR
2007 May 6 3030 5   3 4 2 1  -   -   -    0 Bias
2007 Aug/Sept 4 2835 0   1  -  3  -   -   -   -    0 Bias
2008 April 3 2140 2   1  -  2  -  2  -   -    1 Bias
2008 May 6 2420 4   3 1 3  -   -  3  -    0 Bias
2008 August 7 4125 10   3 2 4  -   -  8  -    2T Bias
2008 Sept 7 1550 1   5 1 2  -   -   -   -    0 Bias
2009 April 2 1708 2   1 2 1  -   -   -   -    0 ASR
2009 May/June 4 4167 2   3 2 1  -   -   -   -    0 ASR
2009 July 4 1984 2   3 2 1  -   -   -   -    0 Bias
2009 Sept 2 1845 1   0  -  2  -   -   -  1B   1(OD) Bias
2010 May 4 3700 3   3 2 1  -  1  -   -    1 Bias
2010 Aug/Sept 5 2227 1   4 1 1  -   -   -   -    0 ASR
2011 May 5 2572 8   4 8 1  -   -   -   -    0 ASR
2011 July/Aug 6 3372 5   4 3 2 1  -  1  -    2(1T) ASR
2011 Sept 6 2076 1   3 1 3  -   -   -   -    0 ASR
2011 Sept/Oct 5 1978 3   3 1 2 1  -  1  -    2(1T)ASR
2012 May 6 3333 8   4 5 2 1  -  2  -    0 ASR
2012 June 3 1381 2   1  -  2 1  -  1  -    0 ASR
2012 Sept 8 2487 10   4 7 4  -   -  2 1B   1(OD) Bias
2013 May 6 1620 7   4 4 2  -   -  3  -    0 ASR
2013 June 6 2187 4   4 3 2 1  -   -   -    0 Bias
2013 July 8 3330 16   5 9 3 2  -  5  -    0 Bias
2013 Sept 4 2767 5   2  -  2 2  -  1 2B   3(2OD-1T) Bias
2014 May 3 1763 3   2 3 1  -   -   -   -    0 Bias
2014 August 8 2139 5   7 5 1  -   -   -   -    0 ASR
2014 Sept/Oct 5 2759 4   4 3 1 1  -   -   -    1 ASR
2015 May 8 3036 3   7 3 1  -   -   -   -    0 Bias
2015 June 8 1117 2   1  -  7  -   -  2  -    0 Bias
2015 Sept 4 2386 2   3 2 1  -   -   -   -    0 Bias
2016 April/May 6 2646 1   5 1 1  -   -   -   -    *0 SBR
2016 June 6 1743 6   3 5 3  -   -  1  -    *0 SBR
2016 Sept/Oct 8 2577 8   6 5 2  -   -  3  -    0 Bias
2017 May 7 1070 1   1  -  6  -   -  1  -    0 ASR
2017 June 7 3112 6   6 4 1 1  -   -  1 ASR   2(1OD) ASR
2017 Sept 3 2310 5   2 4 1  -  1  -   -    1 Bias
 
Year/Month Vehicles total Kms Flats total   Vehicles with T/L T/L Radial flats Vehicles with tubes Radial Tubed flats Bias Tubed flats Tube flats Old Damage   Mick's Flats total
41 Tours 215 96700 156   125 98 88 15 4 34 5   19

 

 Tubeless Tyres

 Tubed Tyres (including Mick & Connie's tyres)

 Mick & Connie's Tyres

 

    As you can see with our tyres once we learnt how to handle and get the best from tubes our flat tyre rate reduced considerably for off-road work. Our last tube issue on a tour was in September 2013. I’ll add here this is not all we have done regarding off-road work, we frequently do trips between our commercial engagements and particularly in the early years we had a good number of flat tyres, it was often at these times I figured out solutions to little niggling problems as I had plenty of time to think as we were on our own and not "on duty". I haven’t included our solitary trips as that would skew the data with all of the other vehicles & tyres.

    With a close look at the tube details you will see that there are times when there are multiple tube issues and they were not from our tyres. Quite simply customers who have split rims in particular don’t often do the right thing in regard to maintenance. So we have tyres & tubes that are not sealed & do not get cleaned & talced regularly. This lack of maintenance has side effects given enough time. (This is the reason split rims have a reputation for slow leaks).

    I forgot to mention, all of our work has been on split rims, that’s right those incredibly dangerous wheels that are solely designed to kill & maim the operator, oh wait, never had a problem. I wonder why that would be......

 

Safe travels,
Regards, Mick Hutton
Copyright : November 2017

 

 

BEADELL TOURS

Mobile : 0408 841 447
Email : Beadell Tours

ABN : 40 947 959 130


Beadell Tours Home           Site map